news Canadian News
Good Evening Guest | login or register
  • Home
    • Canadian News
    • Popular News
    • News Voting Log
    • News Images
  • Forums
    • Recent Topics Scroll
    •  
    • Politics Forums
    • Sports Forums
    • Regional Forums
  • Content
    • Achievements
    • Canadian Content
    • Famous Canadians
    • Famous Quotes
    • Jokes
    • Canadian Maps
  • Photos
    • Picture Gallery
    • Wallpapers
    • Recent Activity
  • About
    • About
    • Contact
    • Link to Us
    • Points
    • Statistics
  • Shop
  • Register
    • Gold Membership
  • Archive
    • Canadian TV
    • Canadian Webcams
    • Groups
    • Links
    • Top 10's
    • Reviews
    • CKA Radio
    • Video
    • Weather

U.S. doctors back Winnipeg family in fight over

Canadian Content
20668news upnews down
Link Related to Canada in some say

U.S. doctors back Winnipeg family in fight over father's life support


Health | 206672 hits | Jan 12 9:17 am | Posted by: WDHIII
11 Comment

A Manitoba lawyer has asked the judge to consider evidence from American doctors in the case of an elderly man whose family wants to keep him on life support, despite his doctors.

Comments

  1. by avatar Brenda
    Sat Jan 12, 2008 8:30 pm
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...

  2. by avatar Heavy_Metal
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 12:58 am
    i have a big issue with keeping people alive with machines.

    Now granted if this guy IS showing signs of improving, then by all means keep his old ass on the machine until he is well enough to fend for himself.

    but if this guy is just going to die, man, LET HIM DIE!! nuts to religion, nuts to the family...with all due respect, if the man is gunna die, he's gunna die, and prolonging his life through artificial means is cruel and very costly.

    The Canadian health care system would save so much money, free up beds, doctors, nurses etc. if they made it easier for people to become DNR, or allow doctor assisted suicide.

  3. by avatar Tricks
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 4:55 am
    "Brenda" said
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...
    Because hospitals are douche bags and won't release patient information to another hospital, nor agree to transport them there. So the people would be taking too large of a risk taking him to the US.

  4. by
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 5:02 am
    "Heavy_Metal" said
    i have a big issue with keeping people alive with machines.

    Now granted if this guy IS showing signs of improving, then by all means keep his old ass on the machine until he is well enough to fend for himself.

    but if this guy is just going to die, man, LET HIM DIE!! nuts to religion, nuts to the family...with all due respect, if the man is gunna die, he's gunna die, and prolonging his life through artificial means is cruel and very costly.

    The Canadian health care system would save so much money, free up beds, doctors, nurses etc. if they made it easier for people to become DNR, or allow doctor assisted suicide.
    Euthanasia... Hmm...

    I agree, lol

  5. by avatar Heavy_Metal
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 4:43 pm
    "Tricks" said
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...
    Because hospitals are douche bags and won't release patient information to another hospital, nor agree to transport them there. So the people would be taking too large of a risk taking him to the US.

    fregg i forgot about the non-sharing of patient information, that has to be the most pea brained and retarded policy i have ever heard!!!

  6. by DerbyX
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 4:48 pm
    "Tricks" said
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...
    Because hospitals are douche bags and won't release patient information to another hospital, nor agree to transport them there. So the people would be taking too large of a risk taking him to the US.

    Actually Ontario is in the process of implimenting a province wide information network that medical professionals can access as needed. Our lab is a key member in helping set up the new LIS.

    Hospitals before this new LIS did release patient info as needed but for obvious reasons concerning privacy they took reasonable precautions.

  7. by avatar Tricks
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 4:52 pm
    "DerbyX" said
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...
    Because hospitals are douche bags and won't release patient information to another hospital, nor agree to transport them there. So the people would be taking too large of a risk taking him to the US.

    Actually Ontario is in the process of implimenting a province wide information network that medical professionals can access as needed. Our lab is a key member in helping set up the new LIS.

    Hospitals before this new LIS did release patient info as needed but for obvious reasons concerning privacy they took reasonable precautions.No I mean they won't release it to another hospital. My mom wanted to move my Dad to toronto after something went wrong, and they wouldn't release the information, nor transport him. She would have to check him out and drive him there, and he wasn't stable enough.

  8. by DerbyX
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 4:56 pm
    "Tricks" said
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...
    Because hospitals are douche bags and won't release patient information to another hospital, nor agree to transport them there. So the people would be taking too large of a risk taking him to the US.

    Actually Ontario is in the process of implimenting a province wide information network that medical professionals can access as needed. Our lab is a key member in helping set up the new LIS.

    Hospitals before this new LIS did release patient info as needed but for obvious reasons concerning privacy they took reasonable precautions.No I mean they won't release it to another hospital. My mom wanted to move my Dad to toronto after something went wrong, and they wouldn't release the information, nor transport him. She would have to check him out and drive him there, and he wasn't stable enough.

    Under the new LIS the information will be online and available as needed.

  9. by avatar Brenda
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 5:22 pm
    "Tricks" said
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...
    Because hospitals are douche bags and won't release patient information to another hospital, nor agree to transport them there. So the people would be taking too large of a risk taking him to the US.

    That is ridiculous...

    He is the patient, shouldn't his family have that info then? And why couldn't they just rent an ambulance with personell? (I know, costly, and not for anybody, but treating your partner in the US wouldn't be free of charge either...)

    On the other hand... He is an 84 year old on life support. How old do you want people to be? Someday their time has come, and you should let them go...

  10. by avatar Tricks
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 6:50 pm
    "DerbyX" said
    If you think the doctors in Winnipeg did not do a good enough job, and you take it to court, using US doctors as second opinion "because they know better", why not have this man treated in the US?

    Obviously, in Winnipeg, he is not getting the treatment his family wants him to have...
    Because hospitals are douche bags and won't release patient information to another hospital, nor agree to transport them there. So the people would be taking too large of a risk taking him to the US.

    Actually Ontario is in the process of implimenting a province wide information network that medical professionals can access as needed. Our lab is a key member in helping set up the new LIS.

    Hospitals before this new LIS did release patient info as needed but for obvious reasons concerning privacy they took reasonable precautions.No I mean they won't release it to another hospital. My mom wanted to move my Dad to toronto after something went wrong, and they wouldn't release the information, nor transport him. She would have to check him out and drive him there, and he wasn't stable enough.

    Under the new LIS the information will be online and available as needed.Good, maybe no one else will have to go through the bullshit we had to.

  11. by avatar Tricks
    Mon Jan 14, 2008 6:51 pm
    "Brenda" said
    He is the patient, shouldn't his family have that info then? And why couldn't they just rent an ambulance with personell? (I know, costly, and not for anybody, but treating your partner in the US wouldn't be free of charge either...)
    Information of the tests they had been doing would not be released, and the tests would have to be re-done.



view comments in forum
Page 1

You need to be a member of CKA and be logged into the site, to comment on news.

  • Login
  • Register (free)
 Share  Digg It Bookmark to del.icio.us Share on Facebook


Who voted on this?

  • WDHIII Sat Jan 12, 2008 10:38 am
Share on Facebook Submit page to Reddit
CKA About |  Legal |  Advertise |  Sitemap |  Contact   canadian mobile newsMobile

All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner.
The comments are property of their posters, all the rest © 2025 by Canadaka.net