Xort Xort:
DrCaleb DrCaleb:
Actually, that is a Citizen's duty. Unjust laws must be openly broken.
See: Ghandi's Salt March.
Unjust laws should be changed by the legally established and accepted methods to change them.
Civil disobedience is the established and accepted method. That's why the right to peaceful assembly and the right to protest are in the constitution.
Xort Xort:
Gun owners in Canada didn't get rid of the LGR by openly breaking the law, they got rid of it by electing a government to change the law.
Pot smokers are not going to get rid of our drug laws by breaking them, they will get rid of them via the political process (maybe).
We should get rid of our census law by politcal means not people saying; "Fuck this law it's stupid I'm not going to follow it."
Actually, no. Gun owners protested by not registering. Pot smokers have "420" smoke ins regularally. And the long form census is long gone.
Xort Xort:
$1:
However, Khawly said he had to acquit Tobias because there was reasonable doubt about her intent. After Tobias testified, Khawly said, he could not be certain that, after more than two years, she was able to accurately tell the court her intent in not filling out the census.
Her intent was to not fill out the form. The reason for not filling out the form is not important.
You can actually justify this opinion, even after all the revalations about the NSA collecting data on just about everyone? And once the new NSA data center is fully operational, they won't collect just 'metadata', but record every aspect of everyone's life.
She (and many others) did not fill out the form because she did not want to give her detailed personal information to the US Government. Motive is always important in court.
Xort Xort:
As for that judges comment about this being a public relations mess; Stick to your own job ass hat. Your job isn't to evaluate the goverment's public relations, and unless you want that to be your job (and the huge pay cut that goes with it) shut your pie hole.
You just don't have the gene that tells you when not to be a douche, do you?